Library Home page | Library Catalog
Skip to Main Content


Gen. John Hathorn of Warwick, NY led the local militia and served on the first Congress of the United States. Learn about John and his wife Elizabeth Welling.

Compiled Service Lists

There are compiled published lists of Hathorn's Fourth Orange County Regiment of Militia, drawn from various sources.  One source is "New York in the Revolution as Colony and State".  The lists reflected the fact that the militia was a fluid unit--- even from the beginning, it was drawn from lower Orange County as well as some areas of northern New Jersey.  As levied companies were shifted and attached to other units, it becomes nearly impossible to track them all. 

Our project has been, wherever possible, to try to determine which men were from the area of Goshen Precinct which later became the Town of Warwick.


James Miller's Commission Signed by Hancock

James Miller of  Warwick, who served in the Continental Army, was one of the few whose commission papers survived the war and were filed with their pension claim.  It was signed by none other than John Hancock on Feb. 24, 1776. [NARA Revolutionary War Pension No. 19881]

Packing List for a Continental Officer

James Miller's pension file also includes an extremely rare broadside published by Fishkill's famous patriot printer, Samuel Loudon.  It details instructions for the enlistee.

The Militia Men: Links to their Documents

The Militia Men: Otherwise Documented

  • Bennett, Abraham, Sr. (1715-1790) - (DAR record) Private in Col. John Hathorn’s 4th Regiment, Orange Co. NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.1, p.229)
  • Bennett, Abraham Jr. (1742-1795) - (DAR record) Private, NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.1, p.229)
  • Bertholf, Petrus(1746-1801) - (DAR record copy)Served in Col. John Hathorn’s 4th Regiment, Orange Co. NY; commissioned 2nd Lieutenant 22 Sep 1775; Captain on 19 Feb 1778 (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.1, p.242)
  • Bertholf, Samuel (1745-1813), married Elsie Alyea.  He signed the Revolutionary Pledge in Goshen NY and served as a Private under Col. Hathorn.  Their daughter Martha married John Ackerman of Ackerman Road in Warwick where in 2015 family member still lives.  John’s father Andrew, after whom Ackerman Road is named, also served in the war but in NJ before he migrated to Warwick. 
  • Bradner, Colvill (1718-?) - "Born in Cape May, NY, served in Capt. MInthorn's Company, Hathorn's Regt.  He died in Goshen, NY. His daughter Martha married Daniel Burt, Jr. (Source: Christiana: His Covenants are Kept by Carrie Rayner Ingham, p. 80-81.  Info. attributed to the Lineage Books of the DAR)
  • Burt, Daniel, Jr. (B. 10/20/1740) - Served in Hathorn's Regt.  Married Martha, daughter of Colvill Bradner. (Source: Christiana: His Covenants are Kept by Carrie Rayner Ingham, p. 80-81.  Info. attributed to the Lineage Books of the DAR)
  • Goldsmith, Richard (1711-1782) - (DAR record) Civil Service [Pathmaster of District Eight] Orange Co. NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.2, p.1182)
  • Holbert, John, Sr. (1741-1829), married Mary Bellas.  He served in the 4th Regiment under Col. John Hathorn, and was a Captain in Col. J. Clinton’s Regiment (DAR record; note: under "Hurlburt" in DAR index)
  • McConnell, Matthew (1739-1817) - (DAR record, pension) Sergeant, Served under Capt. Petrus BERTHOLF, NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.2, p.1948)
  • Miller, Alexander (1758-1843) - (DAR record copy, pension) Private under Col. John Hathorn; Sergeant under Col. Weisenfelt, NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.2, p.2022)
  • Norman, John, Capt. (1735-1795) Captain in Sterling Co. (all forgemen, according to Hathorn in 1779). Born Cornwall, England on April 17, 1735. Died 1795, Sussex Twp., NJ. Burial: Sparta Methodist/Presbyterian church cemetery, Main St. and Lafayetted Rd., Sparta NJ. Spouse: Rachel. Source:
  • Stevens, Elisha and brothers Jonathan, David, and Joseph all served with Hathorn.  Stevens homestead shown on Erskine 1779 map, east of Wickham Lake.
  • Sutton, John, Sr., 1736-1818,  married Deborah Bennett, both faithful members of the Old School Baptist Church in Warwick (and slave holders).  He served in the Orange County Militia as a 2nd Lieutenant under Captain John Wisner, Jr. and under Colonels John Hathorn and Nicholls. (DAR record)
  • Vail, Isaiah (1731-1810) - (DAR record) Captain, Orange County, NY Militia (New York in the Revolution)
  • Wisner, Henry (1742-1812) - (DAR record) Captain in the Pond Co. of the Florida and Warwick Regiments under Col. John Hathorn, commissioned 22 Sep 1775;  Commissioned Lt. Col 19 Feb 1778, NY (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.3, p.3266)
  • Wisner, John (1722-1778) - (DAR record copy) Captain, NY [also in the French and Indian War] (DAR Centennial Edition, Pt.3, p.3266)


  • Miller, James (c.1747-June 27, 1831) Commissioned Feb. 24, 1776, 2nd Lieut. in Capt. Daniel Denton's 2nd company, 3rd New York regiment.  Promoted to st Lieutenant in Captain Charles Graham's co., Col. Philip Van Dorland's 2nd New York Regiment.  Served until April 6, 1778, was dischared at Valley Forge.  In Battles of White Plains, Trenton, and Saratoga(NARA Pension No. 19881)

Cemeteries: Their Final Resting Place



This list gives burial location for men who were of Hathorn's militia and other units, including War of 1812.  Many thanks to the Warwick American Legion Post 214 for their faithful marking with a flag of the graves, and the diligent lists they have developed and kept over the years.

1. Locust Hill/Belcher Cemetery (Rt. 94 near the intersection of Belcher Rd.) (rear section)

  • Wood, John L. (War of 1812)
  • Dill, George (Rev War)
  • Post, Garret (Rev War)
  • Demorest, Cornelius (Rev War)
  • Feagles, John (Rev War)
  • Demarest, Jacobus (Rev War)
  • Bertholf, Henry (Rev War)
  • Bertholf, Jacobus, Gen. (Rev. War)
  • Clark, James D. (Rev. War)
  • Bertholf, Crynis (Rev. War)