Library Home page | Library Catalog
Skip to main content

Understanding Comics Discussion Guide: Home

Scott McCloud

(Photo via)

More information about the author is available on his website.

Follow Scott McCloud on twitter.

Articles, Interviews, and Reviews

Other Works by Scott McCloud

Videos

Discussion Questions

(From Reading with Pictures)

Chapter 1 – Setting The Record Straight – pp. 2

  • What is McCloud’s dilemma regarding comics as the book begins?
  • What’s the difference between pictures and comics?
  • According to McCloud, why isn’t it easy to define comics?
  • To what definition does he eventually arrive?
  • List the ancient civilizations that had some form of comics.

Chapter 2 – Vocabulary of Comics – pp. 24

  • What is an icon?
  • How does knowing what an icon help you “get” the author’s point about the “Treachery of Images”?
  • Discuss the concept of the universality of the cartoon. How/why does this concept help readers of comics?

Chapter 3 – Blood in the Gutter – pp. 60

  • In comics, what is “the gutter?”
  • Discuss the concept of closure as it relates to comics.
  • Of the six types of transitions in comics, choose one that you find most interesting and tell why.
  • What’s the point of the three stories about Carl that are shown on pages 84-85?

Chapter 4 – Time Frames – pp. 94

  • Is each frame in a comic a single moment in time? Why or why not?
  • How does adding words change the length/time of a panel?
  • In comics, time and space are “one and the same.” How so?
  • On page 101, how does changing a panel’s shape affect its time?
  • In comics, motion is usually reduced to what?

Chapter 5 – Living in Line – pp. 118

  • How are emotions made visible using different cartooning styles?
  • Describe how lines are used to represent both visible and invisible phenomena (pp 128-129)
  • What can backgrounds help show?
  • How can word balloons and lettering help show emotion? Cite specific examples.

Chapter 6 – Show and Tell – pp. 138

  • According to McCloud, children are expected to “combine words and pictures” as long as they do what?
  • Throughout history, what happened between words and images?
  • Of the seven types of picture-word combinations, choose one and tell which is the most interesting to you and why?

 Chapter 7 – The Six Steps – pp. 162

  • Does McCloud considers comics to be art? Why or why not?
  • List the path of creating art (Six Steps)
  • Of the Six Steps of creating Art, which step does the artist decide if it will be a book or painting or song or movie or comic?
  • What is the question that is found at the core of all art?

 Chapter 8 – A Word About Color – pp. 185

  • What are the three colors that when put together reproduce every color on the spectrum?
  • As color was added to newspaper, what two things increased?
  • What types of colors were superheroes printed in?
  • What is communicated more clearly in black and white?
  • Do you think color help add “reality” to comics?

Chapter 9 – Putting It All Together – pp. 195

  • Using the last panel on page 195, describe the process that comics use to transmit ideas from one person to another.
  • In this chapter, McCloud summarizes all of the concepts presented in his book. Choose one and describe why it is interesting to you, or why it still confuses you.
  • What is one major idea that you learned about comics after reading this book?
  • Do you see comics differently now? Why or why not?

Suggestions for further reading